A new PLATO study has collected data about the open access journals, meaning scientific articles can be published and read free of charge, and highlighted the sometimes difficult working and publishing conditions.
From March to September 2022, the Platinum Open Access Funding (PLATO) project conducted a study of the Swiss Diamond Open Access landscape, the results of which have just been published. Diamond or Platinum Open Access refers to journals and platforms that are free of charge for both authors and readers and are run by the scientific community. The goal of the PLATO project and similar initiatives is to shift control of science communications back into the hands of researchers and to make open access publishing accessible to all without having to bend to the interests of for-profit publishing companies.
The study provides the first overview of Diamond Open Access journals in Switzerland, following the example of the large-scale international OA Diamond Journals Study of 2021. The PLATO project is a joint initiative of the University of Zurich, the University of Geneva, the University of Bern, University of Neuchâtel, ETH Zurich and the Zurich University of the Arts.
186 Diamond Open Access journals
The study (see box for details) provides interesting insights into a publishing landscape that has grown steadily since 2010. Currently, there are 186 Diamond Open Access journals in Switzerland covering a wide range of disciplines and in various languages. Among them are the journals hosted on UZH’s Diamond Open Access platform HOPE, as well as platforms provided by other Swiss universities.
The majority of the journals are published by researchers or research teams at universities and by the scientific academies. The disciplinary specializations and local connections combined with strong international reach make the journals attractive for writers and readers alike.
In particular, such journals enable researchers to communicate and share their findings with others, regardless of commercial interests. One of the editors describes their journal as a service to the academic community: “If the community thrives, the journal thrives.”
Low budgets and volunteers
On the financial side, the situation unfortunately looks less rosy. The journal editors often work with very small budgets and rely on volunteer work performed by researchers in their spare time. The amount of effort involved is difficult to quantify. On average, it costs about CHF 15,000 per year to run a Diamond Open Access journal; many editorial offices manage with even less, and only a few journals have a budget of over CHF 100,000.
Few journals can afford to outsource the editorial work involved, and researchers often have to take on tasks such as peer review, proofreading, typesetting and hosting. The lack of sustainable funding options to support ongoing operations was thus a key and recurring theme in both the interviews and the survey conducted in the PLATO study.
In addition, the study identified a lack of advisory services and information on best practices in areas such as indexing in databases, long-term archiving or providing metadata for articles. Even though many editors are cautiously optimistic about the outlook for the coming year, this positivity drops considerably when looking at the medium-term stability of their journals over the next three years.
A first step
The study examining the Diamond Open Access landscape in Switzerland and the specific challenges of this publication model formed an initial stage of the PLATO project. Based on the findings, strategies for sustainable promotion of Diamond Open Access journals will be developed over the next two years in cooperation with universities, libraries, scientific academies and funding institutions.
The PLATO project, as a broad-based joint initiative of six Swiss universities, is ideally positioned to do this. European initiatives to promote Diamond Open Access, such as the DIAMAS project, can provide orientation for the planning and implementation of such strategies.
The results of the three-part study were published under the title “Mapping the Swiss Landscape of Diamond Open Access Journals. The PLATO Study on Scholar-Led Publishing.” For the study, which was conducted in collaboration with the Institute of Applied Data Science & Finance at Bern University of Applied Sciences, a list of those journals that meet the Diamond Open Access criteria was first compiled via a database search and by asking Swiss open access experts. In a second step, interviews were conducted with selected editors to provide a deeper insight into their working methods and the specific challenges they faced. Thirdly, three surveys were conducted among the editors, hosting and funding institutions, and authors of all the Swiss Diamond Open Access journals identified in step one. Study
Text by Daniela Hahn; a cultural studies scholar and manager of the Platinum Open Access Funding (PLATO) project at the University of Zurich. English Translation by Caitlin Stephens
Platinum Open Access Funding (PLATO)
PLATO is a project initiated by six Swiss universities and co-funded by swissuniversities to develop a sustainable funding model that enables collaborative community-driven and high-quality Open Access Publishing in Switzerland. Platinum Open Access (also known as Diamond Open Access) refers to publishing and accessing scholarly publications without price barriers for authors and readers.
In the framework of this project, the Platinum publishing landscape in Switzerland will be examined across different disciplines as a first step in order to devise a sustainable model for funding and supporting Platinum Open Access Publishing.
The PLATO project contributes to the implementation of the National Open Access Action Plan and is part of the commitment by UZH to fostering and supporting an open science culture.
The project partners are the University of Zurich, the University of Bern, the University of Geneva, the University of Neuchâtel, the Zurich University of the Arts, the ETH Zurich and the Swiss Academy of Humanities and Social Sciences (SAGW).
January 2022 – December 2024
Danielle Bütschi (University of Geneva)
Dr. Thomas Eichenberger (ETH Zurich)
Dr. Beat Immenhauser (SAGW)
Felix Falkner a. i. (Zurich University of the Arts)
Prof. Dr. Rudolf Mumenthaler (University of Zurich)
Dr. Dirk Verdicchio (University of Bern)